Ask the Band: Wildly Romantic or Mis-Timed & Over the Top?

Here at The Band, we believe in kicking stigmas to the curb, flinging glitter, and shining a light into the dark. And now? Your bandmate needs a sounding board.

It's time to Ask The Band!

I'm tempted to orchestrate a wildly elaborate, romantic gesture for my wife of over twelve years. One with the sort of plot that will require a significant investment of time, money, and the partnership of several friends and family.

But I'm afraid.

Things have not been great for...a while really.

She inherited an addictive personality, which has exhibited itself in alcoholism and a tendency toward workaholism.

This has often left me feeling neglected on a number of levels.

I don't want a grand gesture to be interpreted as anything other than an expression of the love I still feel for her - because I do love her.

I often feel hurt and lonely, but I can't imagine life without her. Okay, that's an exaggeration. I can imagine life without her, but it's never an improvement.

So, if this grand gesture isn't an effort to "win her back," what's driving it?

For a decade, she has expressed an interest in renewing our vows. For various reasons, our church ceremony was disappointing and, perhaps, a little hurtful to her.

We are now part of a church that we agree on and have pastors to whom we feel close.

I also feel that I've been getting little hints from the aether: locations that seem perfect for a renewal ceremony, party, or both; articles and videos that I find inspirational for theme or approach; other people doing things in non-traditional ways that somehow sound right to me.

Maybe it's the coffee this morning, but sharing these thoughts with you gives me a bit of a thrill. My heart is racing. In a good way.

My current idea - and believe me, this is still in the brainstorming phase:

We have a theme (to be called "Theme X" from here forward). I want to recruit my artistic friends and family to help design the event from the ground up to suit "Theme X." Bridal party garb, locations, decor - the whole works.

I think I want to make it as stress-free for her as possible. Not a full-fledged surprise, as she doesn't like surprises. Perhaps a "I've planned an event - keep the date free, I will provide clothing, and everything" type of thing.

I definitely want to incorporate our existing church community, both because it is a community that we've chosen together and because we sincerely like the pastoral staff.

Community involvement is important to me. She sometimes feels that she does not have many friends.

I want this to remind her just how many people love her - and us.

I have done minor surprises in the past, recruiting friends to come into town or planning little trips out of town for her. She is usually hesitant but has always had fun.

I don't know though. It feels like a lot of work, and I don't want it to be perceived as trying to "fix things" or to "pressure her."

I don't mind the work, but rejection of the effort could be devastating.

So I ask you, The Band: Is this a wildly romantic gesture, or is it an over-the-top disaster waiting to happen?

6 Comments
A note about commenting: It only takes moments to comment but makes a world of difference to an author to know they are not alone: They're with the Band! Please share your support here!

Comments

  • layladylay says...
    June 21, 2012, 4:42 p.m. 28144

    Your wife sounds a LOT like me. And I am not a fan of surprises. It sounds to me like this might be a huge success, if you work on it together. It might be just what you both need to open up to each other again. Leaving her out of the planning may just give her things to complain about and make her feel left out. Tell her you have been thinking a lot about doing it and have some ideas. She will be happy it even crossed your mind and working on this "project" together may just be what the Dr ordered.

  • thepsychobabble says...
    June 21, 2012, 5:30 p.m. 28145

    Romantic idea. BUT. I'd let her in on it. I don't know your wife, but I would definitely want a hand in planning it, if it were me. Just my two bits.

  • lifeasiknowit2010 says...
    June 21, 2012, 7:20 p.m. 28146

    I like it! Have you read "the wedding" by Nicholas sparks? Much the same a your idea. Definitely don't surprise her but make it about something YOU are doing for HER and I think it could bens huge success. Good luck and please post when it's done I'd love to hear how it went

  • MKP says...
    June 22, 2012, 11:10 a.m. 28157

    My gut says be wary - I think your gesture is fantastic, and communicating the plan to her is the surprise part - "I would like to do something to show you how much I love you. I was thinking of doing X, and Y, and asking people we love to participate, and I'd love to hear from you if this is something that you'd enjoy doing, and if so, what would make this special for you." If there are areas you'd like to leave as surprises, give her a sense of the scope (I'd like to invite around 100 people) without giving her the specifics (and your long lost BFF back from the Amazon!) And be prepared for her to say no. A gesture like this can be gorgeous (and your wanting to do it is a very sweet and admirable impulse), but if the cracks that need addressing are in the base of something, the sweetest frothiest meringue on the top isn't going to "fix" it.

  • IWantThursdays says...
    June 22, 2012, 4:41 p.m. 28167

    I think it sounds like a beautiful gesture. You obviously know that she would like to renew vows and want to make it stress-free. I think you need to include to her to some extent so that she is not overwhelmed with the "surprise" nature of it all. Most of all, go with your gut. Good luck.

  • thedivasmommy says...
    July 11, 2012, 9:43 p.m. 28776

    Beautiful, Romantic, Wish my hubby would do this gesture. Go for it, Don't go super extravagant, but go for it. She will love it, but don't go too overboard, and try to include her a little (we ladies like to plan) so she isn't so surprised she goes into shock. Good luck.